40 + Style Everlane

Everlane Review: The Heeled Oxford

I had been wanting to jump on the menswear-inspired shoe bandwagon for a while but was waiting for a pair that really spoke to me. I wanted some that were manly, yet feminine. You know… The elusive perfect shoe that is super hard to find. However, As soon as I saw the Heeled Oxford from Everlane I knew it was the shoe I had been looking for.

I had never ordered any shoes from Everlane, but since they were made in Italy I decided to give it a go. I had read many positive reviews about their shoes. Worst case scenario, I hated them and had to send them back. It would be a pain in the tookus, but not the end of the world.

I placed my order and not so patiently waited for them to arrive. You guys…  They were beautifully made. You know I love well made, quality shoes. These were good. REALLY GOOD. Unfortunately, they were too small. (I told you I was still figuring out the sizing at Everlane.) I sent them back and reordered them in the next size up.

Winner, winner, chicken dinner! The next pair fit and I love them! PRO TIP: They run small. I wear an 8 or 8.5 and ended up with a 9. I love the chunky heel. The height gives the shoe a bit of femininity, but does not affect walkability. They are still a bit stiff, but I know they will break in nicely after a few wears. I wore them all day to work one day this past week and didn’t get one blister. Winning!

Athleta black merino sweater, J. Crew denim skirt, Everlane heeled oxfords, 40 + style blogger, 40 + fashion blogger black and denim fall casual weekend look, over 40 style blogger, over 40 fashion blogger Everlane black heeled oxfords review post black sweater, frayed denim skirt, black tights look, 40 + style blogger, 40 + fashion blogger over 40 style blogger, over 40 fashion blogger, black sweater, denim skirt, Wearing: Sweater – Athleta (runs big, size down), Skirt – J. Crew, Tights – Target (Merona), Bag – Coach (old), Shoes – Everlane.


Thanks so much for stopping by! I appreciate it so much.




* FULL DISCLOSURE – The link I included to Everlane tracks how you were introduced to Everlane. If you happen to purchase anything I get a $25 store credit. They provide this to all customers. I’m not special. This post is not sponsored in any way and I’m providing my true honest opinion.

3 thoughts on “Everlane Review: The Heeled Oxford”

Comments are closed.